Ricky Gervais - The Invention of Acting - Badly

Page: 1 2 3
Reply
Author Topic: Ricky Gervais - The Invention of Acting - Badly
Baumski
Avatar of Baumski
Member
Posts: 1730
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

I watched 'The Invention of Lying' at the weekend and realised, finally, realised - not that I haven't thought it for some time - how limited Ricky Gervais is an actor.

Every action and reaction is Gervais/Brent/Millman/and N.E Other charcter he plays. The best laugh was when Stephen Merchant and Shaun Williamson had cameos reprising their roles in 'Extras'. And now I understand why I just don't get James Corden; He and Ricky Gervais are no different right down to the laughter.

Ricky Gervais - what's the point?
 
A quote from my best-seller 'To be or Not To be, Innit' has been included in Stephen Fry's new book 'Planet Word'.

On my blog today:
The Downfall of a Bent Politician Called Margaret Moran http://martinbaum.co.uk/viewfromthehut.asp?Docid=183
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
Matthew Stott
Avatar of Matthew Stott
Member
Posts: 19365
Location: England
View user's profile Permalink 

I'd say the point is great shows like The Office and Extras.

I'd also say he's no more limited in range then a lot of famous comedy actors, who basically have a known persona that they play out in every film/show they appear in. Look at Woody Allen, he's hardly a freaking chameleon from film to film. He's Woody Allen.
 
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
David Bussell
Avatar of David Bussell
Resigned Member
Posts: 9999
Location: England
Permalink 

Quote: Baumski @ April 13 2010, 10:54 AM BST

I watched 'The Invention of Lying' at the weekend and realised, finally, realised - not that I haven't thought it for some time - how limited Ricky Gervais is an actor.

Every action and reaction is Gervais/Brent/Millman/and N.E Other charcter he plays. The best laugh was when Stephen Merchant and Shaun Williamson had cameos reprising their roles in 'Extras'. And now I understand why I just don't get James Corden; He and Ricky Gervais are no different right down to the laughter.

Ricky Gervais - what's the point?


He's a fantastic actor and has spawned many, many imitators. No argument that his performances are one note but it's a note that's played very well.
 
"Chaucer of chuckles"
www.davidbussell.com
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
chipolata
Avatar of chipolata
Member
Posts: 29346
Location: England
View user's profile Permalink 

Gervais is limited - and his best work's behind him - but he's still one of the dominant comedy figures of our time. The Office is a stone cold classic, both in writing and performance, and although flawed, Extras is pretty damned excellent. The comedy world would be a poorer place without him.
 
D21 F205 H4
Quote this post
 
Dolly Dagger
This user has no avatar
Member
Posts: 10475
Location: England
View user's profile Permalink 

I think within his acting limits he's brilliant. Do you remember the Comic Relief when he was pretending to be in Africa and was talking to the African guy and was crying - it was a fantastic bit of acting.
Quote this post
 
Tuumble
Avatar of Tuumble
Member
Posts: 4470
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

There is no doubt that is abilities are limited as has been said but he does what he does very well.

I always remember a bit from the Office where he interrupts Gareth with a mumble and I thought that was clever. People do do that. It's just a way of trying to prevent the other person saying too much so it proves it doesn't always have to be words to make a point.

I suspect he's a bit concerned about his future long term as there's a limit to how far you could stretch that persona. I suspect that in 10 years there will be people saying "Ricky who?"
Quote this post
 
Matthew Stott
Avatar of Matthew Stott
Member
Posts: 19365
Location: England
View user's profile Permalink 

Quote: Tuumble @ April 13 2010, 11:19 AM BST

I suspect that in 10 years there will be people saying "Ricky who?"


Not if they know anything about great comedy.
 
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
Marc P
Avatar of Marc P
Member
Posts: 17467
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

Apparently he has been asked to write and appear in an episode of Doctor Who for the next series.
Quote this post
 
Tursiops
Avatar of Tursiops
Member
Posts: 9607
Location: England

Online

View user's profile Permalink 

That news does not fill me with unconfined joy.
Quote this post
 
Tuumble
Avatar of Tuumble
Member
Posts: 4470
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

Quote: Matthew Stott @ April 13 2010, 11:23 AM BST

Not if they know anything about great comedy.


I should say that I have all the Office and Extras DVDs so I am a fan but I just get the sense that he's already peaked and it's hard to see how he (or anyone for that matter) could match the success he achieved in those early days.

Maybe he won't disappear of the face of the planet but the conveyer belt of awards is coming to close. If that means we are spared the jokes about how many he's had then all the better. I laughed the first few times but he's been using that line for too long now.
Quote this post
 
zooo
Avatar of zooo
Global Moderator
Posts: 67416
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

If there's a problem with some of the films he's appeared in, it's not his acting.
 
Quote this post
 
Matthew Stott
Avatar of Matthew Stott
Member
Posts: 19365
Location: England
View user's profile Permalink 

Quote: Marc P @ April 13 2010, 11:37 AM BST

Apparently he has been asked to write and appear in an episode of Doctor Who for the next series.


I'm assuming you've just made that up.
 
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
john lucas 101
Avatar of john lucas 101
Member
Posts: 7128
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

I've only seen him in Ghost Town. That was ok. Not a great recommendation, but I don't think he wrote that one, did he?

I think he deserves a certain amount of kudos for not just writing himself the main part in Cemetry Junction. Shows that he's, hopefully, more interested in the stories that he's telling than merely getting centre stage.

I really don't think he's somehow going to be forgotten in 10 years time. One or two dodgy fims hardly invalidates an otherwise superb body of work. There are plenty of people thought to have peaked long ago, and yet are still remembered and revered. eg Steve Martin.
 
Favourite Retweet Report Ignore Have sex with
https://twitter.com/seanquigley101
Visit the author's Website Quote this post
 
zooo
Avatar of zooo
Global Moderator
Posts: 67416
Location: England

Offline

View user's profile Permalink 

Quote: john lucas 101 @ April 13 2010, 1:07 PM BST

I've only seen him in Ghost Town. That was ok. Not a great recommendation, but I don't think he wrote that one, did he?


Exactly, Cemetery Junction is the first film that is properly by him. All the others he's just acted in, really.
 
Quote this post
 
Tursiops
Avatar of Tursiops
Member
Posts: 9607
Location: England

Online

View user's profile Permalink 

Quote: Matthew Stott @ April 13 2010, 1:04 PM BST

I'm assuming you've just made that up.


Given the writers Moffat has been recruiting it would not come as a surprise.
Quote this post
 
Reply
Page: 1 2 3