Edinburgh Fringe 2010 Comedy Reviews and Listings

This is our Edinburgh Fringe 2010 section. 2013 Coverage

Jollyboat

By Mark. Published: 23rd August 2010

3 1/2 Stars 3½ Stars

Jollyboat. Image shows from L to R: Ed Croft, Tommy Croft. Jollyboat, a musical comedy duo from Liverpool, have everything needed to become one of the hits of this year's Free Fringe. The two brothers are instantly likeable and have some great comical songs, something they demonstrated when they totally stormed the Musical Comedy Awards Showcase on Saturday 14th.

Tom and Ed Croft open their nightly show at the Opium Bar with their best song, in which they take a number of popular modern classics and give them a unique pirate twist. It would be un-fair to quote back some of the brilliant lyrics here because, although they're funny lines in their own right, they wouldn't be accompanied by Tom and Ed's musical delivery which adds an extra layer. The duo are bouncy, energetic, smiley and have their timing spot on - it's a brilliant opening and really sets up the audience for the rest of the show.

Their second number is equally fun - it's a catchy love song, but the lyrics are, at times, decidedly less than romantic. The audience clearly love it.

As every comedy act knows, sustaining a solid hour of high-energy songs would be too much though, so the action makes way for a slow, quiet solo story next. This extended tale about superheroes takes up a good length of time, but that's fine as the story is delivered with some real subtle acting skill and has some clever gags concealed within it.

Next Tom and Ed hand over to their friend David Alnwick - a comedy magician who, by his own admission, does somewhat remind one of Ron Weasley out of the Harry Potter films. Alnwick has a confident way and is clearly comfortable bantering with the audience, but frankly his magic tricks aren't quite in the same league as some of the other more established magicians performing at the Fringe. The tricks take a while to perform, and this section probably goes on one trick too long.

A slow ballad about a fish & chip shop girl then follows. It's a slow song and, although no doubt beautifully sung, it is not intended to be comical. This is a problem frankly - most of the crowd have come for an hour of comedy, not to see a demonstration of how to sing nicely. There's plenty of music shows elsewhere on the Fringe for serious music lovers - a comedy show is not the place for something deep. It's quite a sad song, which brings the mood down a notch and undoes all the hard work the duo put into getting the energy into the room at the start.

Thankfully with the next song it is back to comedy, and a clever idea and comical accent are enough to bring the mood back up again. Jollyboat then close with a song about Jesus. Thankfully it's not a happy-clapping 'God is great' finale though but something a bit more controversial (but not to the extent it would offend). It's a great end to the show.

In summary, Jollyboat have about 35 minutes of top quality entertainment but let themselves down with a heavy lull two thirds into the show. If they can come up with a couple of sketches and/or comical musical pieces to replace the current 'filler' in the middle, they will be in possession of a solid five star comedy show. They're not there yet, but I'm sure given a year they can be. Despite the lull, Jollyboat is still the most fun I've had on the Free Fringe and so comes heartily recommended.

Listing for 'Jollyboat'

2013 Features

Top 10 best Edinburgh shows

Top 10 best Edinburgh shows

A list of the ten comedy shows at the Edinburgh Fringe festival which picked up the best press reviews. Read

Malcolm Hardee Awards 2013

Malcolm Hardee Awards 2013

Adrienne Truscott and Barry Ferns have won the Malcolm Hardee Comedy Awards for their unique actions. Read

Nominees as paper people

Nominees as paper people

See paper models of the seven contenders for the main Edinburgh Comedy Award 2013. Read

Has anyone seen a coach?

Has anyone seen a coach?

Has anyone seen a coach? The driver from Go Northern is anxiously still looking for his vehicle... Read

PBH Free Fringe football

PBH Free Fringe football

A team of comedians from PBH shows lost out to the 'Rest of the Fest' in a charity football match. Read

Russian LGBT gig videos

Russian LGBT gig videos

A big crowd turned out for a LGBT gig organised by Mark Thomas outside the Russian Federation. Read

So You Think You're Funny?

So You Think You're Funny?

Demi Lardner and Edd Hedges have jointly won the 'So You Think You're Funny?' new act competition. Read

Musical Comedy Picks

Musical Comedy Picks

BCG takes a look at five musical acts that have been impressing at the Edinburgh Fringe this year. Read

Nick Helm interview

Nick Helm interview

Nick Helm talks about using Edinburgh as a tool for comedy progression, and discusses his sitcom plans. Read