Thought I'd create a proper thread to discuss the new series than continue to populate an old one.
I thought tonight's return was a reasonable effort. The signs of the show's tiring do remain evident, and I think this new 'as live' format worsens, rather than ameliorates, the obviousness of that (especially in some of the dialogue given to, and characterisation of, Lucy) - at least tonight. Nonetheless, it turned into a decent and entertaining episode after a plodding first few minutes also beset by dodgy camerawork. I was impressed at how the episode wasn't struggling to fill in before/get to - and how it segued onto - the twist that the promo image for the episode rather spoiled.
I've gotta say, the show surpassed my expectations after some rather coarse reviews over on Reddit earlier today. The new setup will take some getting used to, and hopefully it'll become second nature after a while. Who knows, it may even lead to greater appreciation of the format of theatrical plays on television - which Mack said in a short interview a couple weeks back was kinda the plan for the series, after his initial plans to do the episodes live was kiboshed by other, understandably nervous, cast members.
I hope the show maintains its decent quality across the run after an uneven last series - and it'll remain to be seen whether it does it because of or in spite of the new format.