Good stuff guys - I made it on to the shortlist too with Rheotricity but alas received no notification. I think they need to put in a notification system into the Circalit account so you get a message/notification actually on your account page - I emailed them to let them know this!

As for the review system, it's okay, sometimes you get really thorough feedback that is really beneficial and sometimes you get skim readers that blather on about 'not enough characterisation'.

Good luck to everyone, off to read 'There's no good porn...'