The lead actors also won in the Best Comedy Partnership category.
Georgia, David and Michael filmed videos to accept the awards:
After Life, the Netflix comedy written by and starring Ricky Gervais, won Best Returning Comedy for a second year running. Fans also voted the star's portrayal of widowed Tony as Best Comedy Performance. Gervais is currently working on the third series of the hit show.
Elsewhere in the awards, Mo Gilligan: Black British & Funny claimed the Best Documentary label.
Ant & Dec's Saturday Night Takeaway was voted as Best Entertainment Show.
As revealed on Tuesday's Loose Women, the awards' Best Breakthrough title went to comedian and presenter Judi Love.
The awards are organised by television blogger Elliot Gonzalez. He explains: "Voting for the sixth annual I Talk Telly Awards took place across two weeks in November, where a record-breaking 500,000 votes were cast, making it the biggest awards yet - in a year where we've never needed television more."
The full list of results across all categories can be seen via italktelly.com
For updates, click the buttons below.