British Comedy Guide

Best reviewed Edinburgh Fringe shows 2015

BCG's 2015 Edinburgh Fringe coverage involved over 1,900 different comedy shows. But which were the best? We collected up more than 5,000 reviews from over 50 publications in August, making us ideally placed to analyse which shows were loved most by the press.

In descending order, here are the comedians who clocked up more than 10 reviews rated 4 or 5 stars. Click on any of the names for to see their full list of reviews.

Nish Kumar: Long Word... Long Word... Blah Blah Blah... I'm so Clever. Nish Kumar. Copyright: Nit TV.Nish Kumar

Alex Edelman: Everything Handed to You. Alex Edelman.Alex Edelman

Felicity Ward: What If There Is No Toilet?. Felicity Ward. Copyright: Eleven Film.Felicity Ward

James Acaster: Represent. James Acaster.James Acaster

Bridget Christie: A Book For Her. Bridget Christie. Copyright: Rocket Pictures.Bridget Christie

Joseph Morpurgo: Soothing Sounds for Baby. Joseph Morpurgo.Joseph Morpurgo

Kieran Hodgson: Lance. Kieran Hodgson.Kieran Hodgson

Sam Simmons: Spaghetti for Breakfast. Sam Simmons.Sam Simmons

Daphne Do Edinburgh. Image shows from L to R: Jason Forbes, Phil Wang, George Fouracres.Daphne

Nick Cody - Beard Game Strong. Nick Cody. Copyright: BBC.Nick Cody

Sarah Kendall: A Day in October. Sarah Kendall.Sarah Kendall

Trygve Wakenshaw: Nautilus. Trygve Wakenshaw.Trygve Wakenshaw

Adam Hills: Clown Heart. Adam Hills. Copyright: BBC.Adam Hills

BEASTS: Live DVD. Copyright: Armada Productions.Beasts

Dane Baptiste: Reasonable Doubts. Dane Baptiste. Copyright: BBC.Dane Baptiste

Mark Steel: Who Do I Think I Am?. Mark Steel.Mark Steel

Minor Delays. Image shows from L to R: Joe Barnes, Abi Tedder, Harry Michell. Copyright: Talkback.Minor Delays

Adam Hess: Salmon. Adam Hess. Copyright: John Stanley Productions.Adam Hess

Festival of the Spoken Nerd: Just for Graphs. Image shows from L to R: Steve Mould, Matt Parker, Helen Arney. Copyright: The Comedy Unit.Festival of the Spoken Nerd

Glenn Wool: Creator, I am but a Pawn. Glenn Wool. Copyright: Little Rock.Glenn Wool

Richard Gadd: Waiting for Gaddot. Richard Gadd.Richard Gadd

Spencer Jones Presents: The Herbert in Proper Job. Spencer Jones.Spencer Jones

The Pin: Ten Seconds with The Pin. Image shows from L to R: Alex Owen, Ben Ashenden.The Pin

Tom Parry: Yellow T-shirt. Tom Parry.Tom Parry

In the Cabaret and Theatre sections of the programme Fake It 'til You Make It, A Gambler's Guide to Dying, Our Ladies of Perpetual Succour, Puddles Pity Party, How to Keep an Alien and Every Brilliant Thing were very well reviewed.

Edinburgh Fringe Best Reviewed Shows.Meanwhile just missing out on the above list, with a still impressive 10 top rated reviews, were Andrew Maxwell, Goose, Max and Ivan, Stewart Lee and Tiff Stevenson. In summary, if you see any of the comedians named on this page coming to a town near you, they're definitely worth getting a ticket to.

We want to stress that this list is biased towards those that managed to convince lots of reviewers to come and see them. There are almost certainly amazing shows missing from this list because they didn't get 10 or more reviews... so do go and see as much live comedy from up-and-coming comedians as you can too!

Most of the review data used to compile the above was sourced by Ian Wolf - a big thanks to him (he won a FringePig award this year for his work); and also a thank you to comedian and data-analyst Gareth Morinan for helping us with the data crunching again (check out his animated Tetris remix video).

To see all the reviews that any comedy show at the 2015 Fringe got, just find it on our site: Browse listings

Share this page