Will Smith's Mid-Life Crisis Management (Radio 4) began with a reasonably ticklish stand-up routine. Smith was explaining how he'd decided to evaluate his life at 35, comparing himself with what others had achieved by that age. Mozart, he noted, "died at 37, leaving a body of work unrivalled in western music". Christ had died and risen again by Smith's age. And then came the bathos. "Chris Tarrant," he added, "had already given us Tiswas."

From there, sadly, it was all downhill; a bit like middle-age itself, you might think. Once we dipped into sketches and characters, this was decidedly creaky and patchy stuff. It felt formulaic too, with Smith the inept bumbler for whom every social situation was a failure. It also featured the lamest Louis Walsh jokes on record, and two posh old fools confusing cars and their wives, with allegedly hilarious consequences. If you're approaching middle age, and worried, don't be: it's not as bad as this.

Elisabeth Mahoney, The Guardian, 18th December 2008

Comedian Will Smith (not to be confused with the American rapper and film star) has co-written this new sitcom in which he stars as himself. Reaching the age of 35 has depressed him at how little he has achieved. After all, he says, Christ had died and risen again by the age of 33, an observation which gives you a notion of the size of Will's fragile ego. So he draws in to this scenario his fictional godfather Peter (played by superb Roger Allam) who each week will invite a special guest to advise him on some perplexing aspect of his life.

Gillian Reynolds, The Telegraph, 17th December 2008

He's a man unaware of how out of kilter he is with the planet, but Will Smith has turned 35 and is concerned by his lack of achievement. Coming across like a more obsessive Adrian Mole, he's without savvy, disgruntled with his lot - and fearful at the thought of doing anything about it. Yet what can you expect from a person who never received birthday presents when he was growing up because his parents thought August was too close to Christmas?

Will Smith's considerable comic skill comes in releasing our inner geek and it's our job to decide how far we should go along with his diagnosis of what's gone wrong with the world. But come on - which one of us wouldn't be enraged by someone who couldn't put the Police Academy movies in order? Oh, so that'll be just me and Will then...

David Brown, The Radio Times, 17th December 2008

Will Smith is one of those people who's always seemed middle-aged, despite being young. But now, he's turned 35 and begun to stress... Such is the setup for Smith's new sitcom, also starring Roger Allam as Will's godfather, Peter.

Scott Matthewman, The Stage, 12th December 2008