The Comedy.co.uk Awards 2010

Another year has passed, and once again we gave you the opportunity to vote for your favourite comedies broadcast throughout 2010. Every new episode of British comedy was included in the nominations (that's over 350 shows!), and voting was fierce. Based entirely on those votes, the results - and the opinions of the Great British public - are as follows:

Best New British TV Sitcom 2010


The Trip. Image shows from L to R: Steve (Steve Coogan), Rob (Rob Brydon). Image credit: Baby Cow Productions.The Trip

A low-energy improvised trip around the Lake District, Lancashire, and the Yorkshire Dales with Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon playing versions of themselves. It doesn't sound like the format for a hit sitcom, and split commentators on our message board fairly evenly down the love it/hate it line, but it grabbed the popular vote for best new TV sitcom of the year.

Tom Hollander's church-based Rev came in a very respectable 2nd place, with Simon Amstell's Grandma's House, BBC Three puppet sitcom Mongrels, and the kitchen-based Whites also scoring well.

Worst New British TV Sitcom 2010

See category above

Trinny & Susannah: From Boom To Bust. Image shows from L to R: Susannah (Susannah Constantine), Trinny (Trinny Woodall). Image credit: T5M Studios.Trinny & Susannah: From Boom To Bust

Originating online as a series of short mockumentary episodes, Trinny & Susannah: From Boom To Bust evidently didn't transfer well for a TV audience. We thought that the duo displayed surprisingly well-tuned comic timing, but Channel 4's broadcast of the highlights of their web series doesn't appear to have impressed many others.

Best Returning British TV Sitcom 2010


Peep Show. Image shows from L to R: Mark Corrigan (David Mitchell), Jeremy Osborne (Robert Webb). Image credit: Objective Productions.Peep Show

The seventh series of this cult sitcom finished just before voting opened, and clearly delighted many. With a general consensus that any perceived drop in quality around Series 5 has since been rectified, the low-rating Channel 4 show evidently remains massively popular with its fans. Two further series have been commissioned by the channel, but the first is unlikely to enter production until early 2012.

This was a particularly tough-fought category, with Miranda and The Inbetweeners only narrowly beaten in the polls.

Worst Returning British TV Sitcom 2010

See category above

Coming Of Age. Image shows from L to R: Jas (Hannah Job), Ollie (Ceri Phillips), DK (Joe Tracini), Matt (Tony Bignell), Chloe (Anabel Barnston). Image credit: British Broadcasting Corporation.Coming Of Age

Despite the clear dislike for teen sitcom Coming Of Age amongst comedy enthusiasts, the show remains very popular with its target audience; it is clear, however, that not many of them visit The British Comedy Guide, as the show gained most 'worst' votes in the poll. However, the loud, crude and rude humour that characterised Series 1 and 2 has been significantly toned down for the forthcoming third series. But will that be enough to save it from the same 'Worst' accolade for 2011...?

The tenth series of My Family also garnered a notable number of negative votes. Series 11 has already been recorded, and is expected within the next few months.

Best British Radio Sitcom 2010


Another Case Of Milton Jones. Milton (Milton Jones). Image credit: Pozzitive Productions.Another Case Of Milton Jones

2010 was definitely a good year for master gagsmith Milton Jones. Thanks to appearances on shows like Mock The Week and Michael McIntyre's Comedy Roadshow, the one-line pun-merchant has shot into the mainstream, and the public love him. He's been writing and performing Another Case Of Milton Jones on Radio 4 since 2005, but he's shot to the top with Series 4 this year.

As in previous years, Victorian epic Bleak Expectations and Hell-set Old Harry's Game also scored extremely well.

Best British TV Sketch Show 2010


That Mitchell And Webb Look. Image shows from L to R: Robert Webb, David Mitchell. Image credit: British Broadcasting Corporation.That Mitchell And Webb Look

Despite eliciting disappointment amongst our message board regulars in comparison to its previous series, the latest series of That Mitchell And Webb Look snatches the Best TV Sketch Show award for 2010. It was an incredibly close fight against The Armstrong & Miller Show right up until polling ended, but the Peep Show stars sneaked ahead to take the crown.

CBBC sketch show Horrible Histories also bagged an impressive proportion of votes, suggesting it is definitely a format to keep an eye on in 2011 - particularly with an adult adaptation, starring Stephen Fry, now well under way.

Worst British TV Sketch Show 2010

See category above

Frankie Boyle's Tramadol Nights. Frankie Boyle. Image credit: The Comedy Unit.Frankie Boyle's Tramadol Nights

Whole forests have been destroyed so that publications from The Sun to The Guardian, The Daily Mail and everything inbetween can write angry things about Frankie Boyle's stand-up and sketch show. It certainly was right on the edge of acceptability in many areas, and voters have made it clear that it was, overall, the 2010 TV sketch show that they enjoyed the least.

Best British Radio Sketch Show 2010


Sarah Millican's Support Group. Sarah (Sarah Millican). Image credit: British Broadcasting Corporation.Sarah Millican's Support Group

With her comedy star rising, will Sarah Millican regret her imminent move to daytime TV? Despite increasing popularity on the stand-up scene, the comic has signed up to be one of ITV's Loose Women. This radio show, in which sketches were fitted around her agony aunt character, came out top of our sketch show poll. Let's hope she can take time away from the ITV stools to write and record a second series in 2011.

Elsewhere, Radio 7's Newsjack, the topical sketch show anyone can write for, did well. Sadly it was a slightly slow year for radio sketch shows, and not enough votes were cast to safely award a 'Worst' accolade for this category.

Best British TV Panel Show 2010


QI. Image shows from L to R: Alan Davies, Stephen Fry. Image credit: TalkbackThames.QI

Brain-box panel show QI has won this award three times previously - and it comes out top of the voting again in 2010. It's true that the show's started to receive a bit of criticism of late, but its position in the vote shows that there are still more than enough fans around, and that the most high-brow of comedy can become a big success.

The BBC dominated this category, with Would I Lie To You? a very respectable second, and Never Mind The Buzzcocks and Mock The Week also proving popular in the poll.

Worst British TV Panel Show 2010

See category above

Celebrity Juice. Image shows from L to R: Fearne Cotton, Keith Lemon, Holly Willoughby. Image credit: Talkback.Celebrity Juice

It'll be back for a fifth series next month, but Celebrity Juice fans and visitors to The British Comedy Guide seem to be two largely separate demographics as, for the second year in a row, Keith Lemon's (Leigh Francis) raucous panel show got the most negative votes in this category.

However, BBC Three's The King Is Dead was a very close 2nd place in the 'worst' stakes - suggesting that hosting (and creating) the show wasn't the best career decision that The Inbetweeners star Simon Bird has made.

Best British Radio Panel Show 2010


I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue. Image shows from L to R: Graeme Garden, Barry Cryer. Image credit: British Broadcasting Corporation.I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue

Despite the change of host, Radio 4's self-styled antidote to panel games continues to please audiences. It's now well into its 54th series and with such popularity shows no sign of slowing.

The Unbelievable Truth and The News Quiz, two other perennial Radio 4 panel shows, also picked up respectable numbers of votes in this category.

Best British TV Entertainment Show 2010


Charlie Brooker's Screenwipe. Charlie Brooker. Image credit: Zeppotron.Newswipe With Charlie Brooker / Screenwipe

This is a new category for 2010, in which the increasing number of stand-up and general entertainment shows were put forward to the public vote. Charlie Brooker's Screenwipe special, rounding-up 2010 on TV, and a second series of the popular variant Newswipe, in which he mercilessly dissects television news coverage, grabbed a win for the acerbic commentator.

Russell Howard's Good News also did very well, and Harry Hill's TV Burp is the only ITV show in any category this year to have picked up a notable number of positive votes.

Worst British TV Entertainment Show 2010

See category above

James Corden's World Cup Live. James Corden. Image credit: Amigo Television.James Corden's World Cup Live

After every main World Cup football match in the summer, James Corden came on telly to broadcast live to the nation. A bold format idea, but it turned out to be a bit of a shouty shambles and clearly failed to win over voters in this category.

Best British Radio Entertainment Show 2010


Image shows from L to R: Dawn French, Jennifer Saunders. French & Saunders

Dawn French and Jennfier Saunders reunited to present a series of entertainment shows for Radio 2 over the Christmas period. Their mix of light-hearted banter, comedy guests and records certainly seems to have been a winning combination based on the votes.

Other comedies to score well in this category were stand-up shows Mark Steel's In Town and Richard Herring's Objective, as well as Marcus Brigstocke's challenge show I've Never Seen Star Wars.

Best British TV Comedy Drama 2010


Misfits. Image shows from L to R: Curtis (Nathan Stewart-Jarrett), Alisha (Antonia Thomas), Nathan (Robert Sheehan), Kelly (Lauren Socha), Simon (Iwan Rheon). Image credit: Clerkenwell Films.Misfits

Comedy drama is tricky to get right: most programmes in this genre normally just fail to be funny enough. However, Misfits, written by Howard Overman, has been getting great ratings for E4 thanks to its mix of comedy and zippy storylines - and it takes away the award for Comedy Drama this year.

Overman picks up a double here, with his BBC Four adaptation of Douglas Adams's Dirk Gently doing very well in this category, particularly so considering it was a single pilot - definitely a sign that the channel should sign up Stephen Mangan & co. for more.

Worst British TV Comedy Drama 2010

See category above

Shameless. Image shows from L to R: Ian Gallagher (Gerard Kearns), Liam Gallagher (Joseph Furnace), Frank Gallagher (David Threlfall), Carl Gallagher (Elliott Tittensor). Image credit: Company Pictures.Shameless

After 7 series, it seems viewers are bored of Channel 4's Shameless. Has the channel become overly-reliant on the Manchester-based comedy drama? The voting in our poll certainly suggests so, and with a stupendously long 22-episode Series 8 now on air, could it pick up the same 'award' in 2011 as well?

We were also somewhat surprised by the number of negative votes cast for Rock & Chips, the Only Fools And Horses prequel, suggesting people haven't got to grasps with the fact that unlike its parent, it's not a sitcom.

Worst Comedy Of The Year 2010

Every new British comedy broadcast in 2010 - 359 nominees in total

Frankie Boyle's Tramadol Nights. Frankie Boyle. Frankie Boyle's Tramadol Nights

There really was quite a bit of hate for Frankie Boyle this year. Controversial jokes such as those involving Katie Price's disabled son, along with his use of "the 'n' word" and similarly contentious language, certainly had the potential to alienate him.

On a less sensitive level, some of his sketches were criticised for being long, drawn-out and boring; we actually felt that the show did have some redeeming features and that there were plenty of stronger contenders for the worst comedy of 2010, but in the voters' minds Tramadol Nights was the worst of the worst, and picked up this ultimate of anti-accolades.

Comedy Of The Year 2010

Every new British comedy broadcast in 2010 - 359 nominees in total

Miranda. Image shows from L to R: Stevie (Sarah Hadland), Penny (Patricia Hodge), Miranda (Miranda Hart), Gary (Tom Ellis). Image credit: British Broadcasting Corporation.Miranda

At the end of the voting process, we asked voters to select what was the overall best comedy of the year. Many people opted for Peep Show or The Inbetweeners, but more selected Miranda than anything else.

Miranda Hart's sitcom is certainly a big success story - its family-friendly storylines, joyful atmosphere and use of techniques such as addressing the camera directly have all worked to establish a big fan-base, and as word-of-mouth spread, ratings rocketed, comfortably passing the 4 million viewers mark for the Christmas-themed episode 6 - absolutely massive ratings for a BBC Two sitcom. With a third series having just been confirmed and interest from BBC One, the future looks very bright indeed for Miranda. Congratulations to all involved.

British Comedy Guide Editors' Award 2010

Roy Clarke. Each year, we keep one award back for something or someone that we at the British Comedy Guide believe deserves some special recognition.

This year, that Editors' Award goes to sitcom writing supremo Roy Clarke, who retired his long-running hit Last Of The Summer Wine - the world's longest-running sitcom - in August after an incredible 37 years. Amassing 31 series and almost 300 episodes, as well as its own spin-off (First Of The Summer Wine), the comedy bowed out with sinking viewing figures but a dedicated core audience and fan-base.

Meanwhile, Keeping Up Appearances, another Clarke-penned sitcom, continues to entertain with regular repeats on the BBC and channels like GOLD, not to mention huge popularity in countries like the USA and Australia.

Roy Clarke also worked with comedy giant Ronnie Barker on a number of occasions, penning the single series The Magnificent Evans, and more notably the long-lasting success story Open All Hours, which also highlighted the shining star of David Jason. Other Clarke sitcoms do not enjoy such repeats nowadays and are accordingly largely forgotten, despite having been popular at the time of their production. Such shows include Arthur Lowe's final sitcom, Potter, as well as The Growing Pains Of PC Penrose, and the 3 series of its successor, Rosie.

Thanks to everyone who cast their vote, and congratulations to all of the winners!

See the results from previous years

 
No Pressure To Be Funny

No Pressure To Be Funny

Our topical political comedy podcast, this month with guests including stand-ups Jo Brand and Andy Zaltzman. Listen

Alex Horne interview

Alex Horne interview

His latest Edinburgh show involved ladders from Wickes, his first one was supposed to feature a bloke from Hot Chip. Read

Jonathan Ross cooking show

Jonathan Ross cooking show

Jonathan Ross is to present a food-themed comedy panel show pilot. The format is described as 'mouth watering'. Read

Missing TV sketch shows?

Missing TV sketch shows?

The organisers of London Sketchfest ponder why there's hardly any sketch shows on TV nowadays. Read

The John Bishop Show

The John Bishop Show

John Bishop will present a new eight-part comedy and entertainment variety show on BBC One on Saturday nights. Read

Channel 5 is back

Channel 5 is back

Good news. Channel 5 is to start showing British comedy again, following a deal with Comedy Central. Read

BBC Salford Sitcom Showcase

BBC Salford Sitcom Showcase

Funz And Gamez, Fishbowl and Barbara Nice are amongst the comedy that will be showcased at the BBC event: Read

Jim Howick to star in Stag

Jim Howick to star in Stag

Jim Howick will star in Stag, a comedy thriller for BBC Two from The Wrong Mans director Jim Field Smith. Read

BBC Two orders 'Mum'

BBC Two orders 'Mum'

BBC Two has commissioned Mum, a new sitcom from the writer and producers of hit BBC Three sitcom Him & Her. Read

Sky Arts slapstick comedies

Sky Arts slapstick comedies

Kevin Eldon, Johnny Vegas, Kim Cattrall, Vic Reeves and Frank Skinner star in four physical comedies on Sky Arts. Read

Ballot Monkeys preview

Ballot Monkeys preview

Top comedy writers Andy Hamilton and Guy Jenkin introduce their new political sitcom, Ballot Monkeys. Read

Channel 4's Election Night

Channel 4's Election Night

Channel 4 is bringing back its Alternative Election Night format on 7th May, with Jeremy Paxman & David Mitchell. Read

Frankie and Benny

Frankie and Benny

Robert Ross celebrates the memories of Frankie Howerd and Benny Hill, who died on Easter weekend 1992. Read

Jan Etherington interview

Jan Etherington interview

We talk to one of the writers of Lynda Bellingham sitcoms Second Thoughts & Faith In The Future, now on DVD. Read

Lee Nelson interview

Lee Nelson interview

Now on a nationwide tour, we talked to Lee Nelson about his plans for the future, politics, and his new look. Read

Friday Night Dinner 4

Friday Night Dinner 4

Channel 4 has ordered a fourth series of Robert Popper's award-winning sitcom Friday Night Dinner. Read

Have you made a short film?

Have you made a short film?

Short Com is open for comedy film submissions for its 2015/2016 touring schedule of screenings. Read

Win a comedy writing book

Win a comedy writing book

We have three copies of Masterclass: Writing Comedy, the new tutorial book by Lesley Bown, to hand out. Enter

Get Started In Stand-Up

Get Started In Stand-Up

We've got some copies of Logan Murray's great tutorial book Get Started In Stand-Up to hand out to comedians. Enter

Dave's Election Night

Dave's Election Night

Channel Dave is to broadcast a one-off documentary focusing on Al Murray as he lobbies in the General Election. Read

Alan Partridge book sequel

Alan Partridge book sequel

A sequel to Alan Partridge's smash hit autobiography, I, Partridge, will be published in 2016. Read

Zig and Zag are back!

Zig and Zag are back!

CBBC has ordered a 26-part animated sitcom series focused around former Big Breakfast characters Zig & Zag. Read

Kevin McHale interview

Kevin McHale interview

Kevin McHale talks about how he nearly said no to hosting Virtually Famous, and panel shows in the USA. Read

BAFTA nominations

BAFTA nominations

The shortlists for the 2015 BAFTA Television Awards have been announced. Here's the comedy nominees: Read

Terry Jones - Bath Plug

Terry Jones - Bath Plug

Monty Python star Terry Jones has received Bath Comedy Festival's first ever 'Bath Plug Award'. Pictures

Blake Harrison gets Tripped

Blake Harrison gets Tripped

The Inbetweeners star Blake Harrison will take the lead role in Tripped, a comedy drama series for E4. Read

E4 orders Aliens comedy

E4 orders Aliens comedy

E4 has ordered Aliens, a show about a group of extra-terrestrials forced to live in a segregated community. Read

Max & Ivan on their R4 show

Max & Ivan on their R4 show

Comedy double-act Max & Ivan attempt to introduce their Radio 4 series to us in this funny article written by them. Read

Bethan Roberts wins in Bath

Bethan Roberts wins in Bath

Bethan Roberts has been named the winner of Bath Comedy Festival's 2015 New Act Of The Year contest. Read

Sue Perkins panel show

Sue Perkins panel show

Sue Perkins will host the pilot episode of Insert Name Here, a new comedy panel show format for BBC Two. Read

As Yet Untitled - Series 3

As Yet Untitled - Series 3

Unscripted chat format Alan Davies As Yet Untitled is to return to Dave for a third series. There'll be 10 episodes. Read

David Mitchell's new sitcom

David Mitchell's new sitcom

David Mitchell has signed up to play William Shakespeare in Upstart Crow, a sitcom pilot for BBC Two. Read

You, Me & Them interviews

You, Me & Them interviews

Seven members of the cast of UKTV Gold sitcom You, Me & Them talk about the second series of their show. Read

39 Steps - 4 play 139 roles

39 Steps - 4 play 139 roles

The 39 Steps is one of the West End's longest-running and funniest plays. We take a look at the show here. Read

Seann Walsh interview

Seann Walsh interview

A quick chat with Seann Walsh about his stand-up tour, and his role as a team captain on Virtually Famous. Read

The Interviews - new series

The Interviews - new series

Kenneth Williams and The Two Ronnies are amongst the comedians profiled in new Gold series The Interviews. Read

Radio 4's Cardboard Heart

Radio 4's Cardboard Heart

The cast has been announced for Richard Marsh: Cardboard Heart, a Radio 4 sitcom about a man who writes poetry. Read

No more Up The Women

No more Up The Women

Jessica Hynes's suffragette sitcom Up The Women will not return for a third series. BBC2 has given it the axe. Read

'This Made Me Laugh' films

'This Made Me Laugh' films

The Barbican has invited eight stars from the world of comedy to select their favourite classic comedy films. Read

ITV's Play To The Whistle

ITV's Play To The Whistle

Holly Willoughby has signed up to present Play To The Whistle, a sports-based comedy panel show for ITV. Read

Ray Peacock: taboo comedy

Ray Peacock: taboo comedy

Ray Peacock explains why he has decided to open up about his suicide attempt in his latest stand-up show. Read

Dad's Army only just made

Dad's Army only just made

A speech by TV executive Huw Wheldon revealed that the BBC nearly didn't make the Dad's Army series. Read

Lemon is Back To The Future

Lemon is Back To The Future

Keith Lemon is to star in a one-off special on ITV2 celebrating the 30th anniversary of the Back To The Future film. Read

Charlie Brooker special

Charlie Brooker special

Charlie Brooker will return to BBC Two in the run-up to the Election with a new hour-long Wipe special. Read

Graham Fellows interview

Graham Fellows interview

Graham Fellows will celebrate his 30th year as John Shuttleworth with a big gig - but could it be his last hurrah? Read

Russell Howard's new show

Russell Howard's new show

Russell Howard's Stand Up Central, which launches in April, will feature guests including Joe Wilkinson. Read

Frankie Boyle's new show

Frankie Boyle's new show

Frankie Boyle will follow his 2014 Scottish independence referendum special with a new iPlayer election show. Read

Doc Martin Series 7 filming

Doc Martin Series 7 filming

Martin Clunes and the rest of the Doc Martin cast are now in Cornwall to film Series 7 of the hit ITV show. Read

Laura Aikman interview

Laura Aikman interview

Laura Aikman talks about joining the cast of Bluestone 42, and how she was 'liquid sweat' filming the show. Read

ITV2 orders Plebs Series 3

ITV2 orders Plebs Series 3

ITV2 has ordered more Plebs, the Ancient Rome sitcom starring Tom Rosenthal, Joel Fry and Ryan Sampson. Read

Nathan Caton interview

Nathan Caton interview

Stand-up comedian Nathan Caton talks to us about various topics, including his ideal comedians football squad. Read

Jack Dee's Help Desk on TV

Jack Dee's Help Desk on TV

BBC Two has ordered Jack Dee's Help Desk, a series starring Jack Dee and a panel of comedians. Read

Michael McIntyre new shows

Michael McIntyre new shows

Michael McIntyre is working on two new series for BBC One, however his chat show format won't return to TV. Read

Images from '50 Comics'

Images from '50 Comics'

Check out some striking pictures from photographer Matt Crockett's book of comedian portraits, 50 Comics. View

Milton Jones interview

Milton Jones interview

Milton Jones talks about big hair, bad shirts, Mock The Week, his mammoth 2015 tour and other topics too: Read

Harry & Paul win RTS Awards

Harry & Paul win RTS Awards

Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse have won two gongs at the Royal Television Society Awards. Read

Rik Mayall - legend award

Rik Mayall - legend award

Rik Mayall has been named as the recipient of the Leicester Comedy Festival 'Legend Of Comedy' award. Read

Harry & Paul to tour

Harry & Paul to tour

Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse are planning their first ever live tour together - Harry & Paul: Legends. Read

Prof Branestawm to return

Prof Branestawm to return

Harry Hill will return as eccentric inventor Professor Branestawm for another one-off BBC special this Christmas. Read

Chortle Award winners

Chortle Award winners

Bridget Christie and James Acaster are amongst the winners at the 2015 Chortle Awards. Full results here: Read